Monday, November 24, 2008

My Review of Planet Bike EZ Fenders - 45mm

Originally submitted at REI

This hybrid/touring fender set is compatible with disc brakes and works with frames and forks without eyelets.


Horrible Experience With These Fenders

By lenandbigred from Longmont, Colorado on 11/23/2008

 

1out of 5

Gift: No

Pros: Lightweight

Cons: Mounting System Sucks, Continual bracket adjust, Breaks or Cracks Easily, Constant rubbing of tires, Comes Loose, Noisy When Hitting Bumps

Best Uses: Touring bike

Describe Yourself: Avid Cyclist

I bought these fenders for my Surly Long Haul Trucker Touring bike. I did a bike trip self supported with UK friend through Thailand, Laos and Cambodia in January/February, 2008. The mounting of these fenders leaves a lot to be desired. The bracket which was provided to mount to the rear fork did not fit without tire/rack interference but it fit perfectly in the front fork. This caused the rear fender, as it lacked adequate firm mounting on top, to constantly rub the tires or whenever I hit a bump in the road. The mounting of the rer fender to the frame hole of the bike left a lot to be desired. These fenders are made out of a cheap plastic, and it cracked almost immediately upon mounting, but because I was in Bangkok at the time, I had to work around it, but the cracking got worse and worse, to where later in the trip, it just broke apart and I had to discard the fender. Upon return to States, I contacted Planet bike about these fenders and was told they had a lifetime warranty and they would send me a new set of fenders...but after repeated contact, I've yet to receive anything. I would not recommend purchasing these fenders at all...they're cheap, the mounting is insufficient, and the fender design is not good at all.

(legalese)

No comments: